Olivia Mediterranean Restaurant
About
Olivia Mediterranean Restaurant is on Wilhelminastraat in central Oranjestad, holding the #53 spot out of 316 restaurants in the capital. The upscale vibe shows in the price tier and the 2025 Travelers' Choice Award, and the numbers back it — food, service, and atmosphere all land at 4.6 or better. The kitchen runs Mediterranean with a seafood tilt and a healthy angle, which sets it apart from the endless Italian and steak options in town. The subratings are tight across the board, including a 4.5 for value, which is solid for this price bracket. This is not a casual walk-in spot, and it's not particularly kid-friendly. Plan accordingly.
At a glance
- Area
- Oranjestad
- Vibe
- upscale
- Price
- ●●●●
- Reservation required
- –
- Kid friendly
- –
- Cuisine
- mediterraneanseafoodhealthy
- Dietary options
- —
Photos
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
Similar restaurants
Oranjestad●●●●© Management via TripAdvisorBarefoot Restaurant
Barefoot sits right on L.G. Smith Boulevard in Oranjestad, claiming the #37 spot among local restaurants and a 2025 Travelers Choice award. The upscale Caribbean-seafood-international menu runs at the top price tier, but unlike Madame Janette or The Flying Fishbone, you can walk in without a reservation — which is the entire appeal if you're staying in Palm Beach and want something nicer without the planning. The catch: noise. A neighboring club sends music across the dining area often enough that conversation becomes work, and beachside tables don't always deliver the views you'd expect at this price point. The 4.6 food rating tells part of the story — experiences vary more than they should. Service and atmosphere both score higher, so execution on those fronts is steadier. If spontaneity matters more than guaranteed quiet or sightlines, Barefoot works. If you're after the romantic beachfront meal without interruptions, Passions On The Beach handles that better without the sound bleed.
Oranjestad●●●●© Management via TripAdvisorL.G. Smith's Steak & Chop House
L.G. Smith's sits inside the Renaissance Mall in downtown Oranjestad — you take the elevator up, which sounds odd until you walk out onto the waterfront terrace. It's been the upscale steakhouse anchor on the island for years, and the #14 ranking among 316 restaurants in town reflects consistency more than flash. The menu is straightforward American steakhouse fare done at a four-dollar-sign level. Service scores highest in the subratings, which tracks with the formal-but-not-stuffy approach. Food and atmosphere both land at 4.6, and the Travelers' Choice nod for 2025 suggests they're holding the line. The value subrating sits at 4.4 — fair given the price tier and the setting. It's not a kids' spot, by design. If you want a proper steak dinner with a water view and you're staying at the Renaissance or walking around Oranjestad after dark, it works. Reservations help but aren't mandatory.
Oranjestad●●●○© Management via TripAdvisorPinchos Grill & Bar
Pinchos sits on a pier off Surfside Beach in Oranjestad, and the setup is the whole draw — tables over the water, unobstructed sunset views, no reservations needed. It ranked #13 among Oranjestad restaurants and picked up a Travelers' Choice award, but that's mostly the location talking. The atmosphere score is higher than the food score, which tells you what you're paying for. The menu leans American-Caribbean with seafood, and the vibe is casual enough for kids. Price tier sits mid-range, below the upscale spots on Eagle Beach but above the cheaper local options. Service and value ratings are solid, so you're not getting gouged, but multiple travelers mention the food itself doesn't match the setting. If you want a pier table at sunset without the formality or the bill that comes with Barefoot or The Flying Fishbone, Pinchos delivers that. Just know you're there for the view, not a standout meal.
Source: TripAdvisor · view on TripAdvisor →
Photos by individual contributors as credited above.
Review summaries are AI-paraphrased from public traveler reviews.