The Old Man and The Sea
About
The Old Man and The Sea sits on the waterfront in Savaneta, a quiet fishing village on the south coast. It's the #3 restaurant in the area out of 22, and the 2025 Travelers' Choice nod backs that up. The $$$$ tag and 4.9 atmosphere subrating point to the same thing: this is upscale romantic dining without the reservation pressure or crowd noise you get elsewhere in the village. The menu runs Caribbean, seafood, and international, and the kitchen holds a 4.4 food rating across 412 reviews. Service scores match at 4.5. The value subrating sits at 4.1, which is solid for the price tier — travelers mention it compares favorably to neighbors charging similar rates but delivering less. The setting works for proposals and anniversaries; multiple reviews call out the private, intimate vibe. Walk-ins are fine. If you want upscale Savaneta seafood without the fuss, this is the move.
At a glance
- Area
- Savaneta
- Vibe
- upscale
- Price
- ●●●●
- Reservation required
- –
- Kid friendly
- –
- Cuisine
- caribbeanseafoodinternational
- Dietary options
- —
How to decide
- ✓You want a private, intimate setting specifically praised for proposals without the crowds or noise issues affecting Barefoot Restaurant
- ✓You prefer avoiding reservation requirements while still getting upscale romantic dining, unlike The Flying Fishbone or Madame Janette
- ✓You're seeking romantic Savaneta dining with better value perception than The Flying Fishbone, which travelers call overpriced and overrated
- You're traveling with children, since Gianni's Ristorante Italiano and The West Deck better accommodate families
- You want multiple confirmed traveler endorsements across various aspects, as Barefoot Restaurant has four personal favorite citations
Unlike The Flying Fishbone next door in Savaneta, which three travelers criticized as overpriced and overrated, The Old Man and The Sea earns consistent praise for intimate proposal-worthy moments without requiring reservations. While Barefoot Restaurant attracts more repeat fans, it suffers from loud music disruptions that would undermine the private romantic atmosphere travelers specifically choose The Old Man and The Sea to experience.
Photos
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
© Management via TripAdvisor© Management via TripAdvisor
Similar restaurants
Savaneta●●●●© JamesO131 via TripAdvisorThe Flying Fishbone
The Flying Fishbone is on the beach in Savaneta, and the setup is adults-only French-Caribbean fusion with tables literally in the water at high tide. That #2 ranking among Savaneta restaurants comes with the second-highest review count in the area, and the 4.9 atmosphere score reflects the whole point of coming here — it's romantic in a way that feels less engineered than the high-rise strip options. The food is seafood-forward, competently done, though the 4.3 value score tells you what you need to know: people debate whether the setting justifies the tier-4 pricing. Service scores well, the French influence shows up in the preparations, and the Caribbean ingredients keep it from feeling like imported fine dining. Reservations are required. If you're booking sunset, know that earlier seatings before 7pm can mean harsh direct light — the magic hour matters here more than at indoor spots.
Savaneta●○○○© 50lesliew via TripAdvisorZeerovers
Zeerovers is a fisherman's shack on the water in Savaneta, and it's about as straightforward as eating gets. You order fried fish by the pound from whatever came off the boat that morning, grab a picnic table on the pier, and eat. The 4.6 value rating makes sense — prices are low, portions are generous, and the seafood is fresh because the boats are right there. The #4 ranking in Savaneta and the 2025 Travelers' Choice award reflect consistent execution more than anything fancy. The atmosphere is open-air Caribbean casual, which means plastic chairs, ceiling fans, and pelicans circling overhead. Service is quick once your order's up, though weekends can stretch the wait. Families do fine here — it's loud, relaxed, and kids can watch the fishing boats come in. Bring cash if you can. The line moves, but it moves at island speed. If you want tablecloths or a wine list, this isn't it. If you want good fried fish without the markup, it is.
Savaneta●●●○© 271genevievem via TripAdvisorLa Tavola By Anate
La Tavola By Anate is tucked into Pos Chiquito, just south of Savaneta, and it's running a perfect 5.0 across food, atmosphere, and service — which is rare enough to notice. The Travelers' Choice nod and the #1 spot in the area aren't accidents; this is upscale Italian done right, with a vibe that manages to feel both polished and relaxed. The value rating sits at 4.9, which suggests the mid-to-high price tier isn't inflated. What stands out is the consistency. Seventy-eight reviews holding a flat 5.0 means the kitchen and front-of-house aren't coasting. It's also marked kid-friendly, so you're not stuck choosing between bringing the family and having a proper meal. Reservations aren't required, but given the numbers and the size of the area, calling ahead probably saves you a wait.
Source: TripAdvisor · view on TripAdvisor →
Photos by individual contributors as credited above.
Review summaries are AI-paraphrased from public traveler reviews.